A seasoned advertising executive, instrumental in shaping some of Bud Light’s most memorable campaigns, has voiced concerns over the brand’s strategic direction, particularly in the wake of its controversial partnership with transgender influencer Dylan Mulvaney. John Immesoete, formerly Group Creative Director at DDB Chicago, suggests that the acquisition of Anheuser-Busch by InBev in 2008 marked a significant shift, wherein the new ownership’s perceived disregard for established brand heritage, exemplified by a questioning of the efficacy of iconic elements like Clydesdale commercials, may have signaled a departure from core brand understanding.
Immesoete, who recently released a documentary examining Bud Light’s historical trajectory, posits that the brand’s foundational success stemmed from an ethos encapsulated by its co-founder Adolphus Busch’s principle of “making friends is our business.” He argues that the collaboration with Mulvaney, rather than fostering connections, alienated a substantial portion of the brand’s traditional consumer base and, by extension, broader segments of the country.
The execution of the Mulvaney partnership, Immesoete suggests, was fundamentally flawed, irrespective of the influencer’s identity. He characterizes the content as poorly scripted and lacking brand alignment, noting its departure from the brand’s characteristic “making friends” narrative. The solitary nature of the communication, featuring a direct address to the audience, failed to resonate as entertaining or relatable, creating an impression of pervasive brand presence that was inherently polarizing. Immesoete expressed difficulty in comprehending the strategic intent behind the specific creative approach.
This strategic misstep in 2023 led to significant repercussions. The social media campaign featuring Mulvaney triggered widespread boycotts, contributing to a reported $4 billion decline in InBev’s market capitalization shortly thereafter. Consequently, Bud Light surrendered its long-held position as the leading beer brand in retail sales to Modelo. Further complicating matters, Bud Light’s then-advertising executive, Alissa Heinerscheid, who departed following the incident, characterized the brand’s previous identity as “fratty, kind of out-of-touch humor” in a 2023 interview, a statement Immesoete believes may have exacerbated the brand’s damage.
Immesoete expressed a somber outlook regarding the brand’s ability to recover from what he terms potentially “irreparable damage” and a contender for the “biggest disaster in marketing advertising history.”
In contrast, Immesoete pointed to American Eagle’s recent campaign featuring Sydney Sweeney as an example of how public backlash can, in some instances, benefit a brand. The advertisement, which showcased Sweeney in American Eagle jeans with the tagline “Sydney Sweeney has good genes,” also generated considerable social media attention. However, Immesoete observed that in this scenario, the negative reactions seemingly amplified the campaign’s popularity, suggesting that consumers who disliked the ad might not have been part of American Eagle’s target demographic. He concluded that while Bud Light appeared to aim for appeal within a specific social media echo chamber, it failed to grasp the preferences of its broader national consumer base.
Lucas turns raw market data into actionable strategies, spotting trends in a heartbeat. With 9 years managing portfolios, he treats market volatility like a surfer riding big waves—balance and timing are everything. On weekends, Lucas hosts “Bull & Bear Banter” podcasts, showing that finance discussions can be as entertaining as they are informative.