India’s Foreign Policy Tightrope: Balancing US Tariffs & Russian Oil Imports

Photo of author

By Nathan Morgan

India finds itself at a critical geopolitical and economic juncture, where the strategic advantage gained from importing discounted Russian oil is now directly clashing with new, substantial tariffs imposed by the United States. This escalating trade tension threatens to erode economic gains and compels New Delhi to navigate a complex foreign policy recalibration with two global powers.

  • India’s economic gains from discounted Russian crude are significant, estimated at over $17 billion since early 2022.
  • New U.S. tariffs, potentially up to 50%, threaten to reduce Indian exports by nearly $37 billion in the current fiscal year.
  • Labour-intensive sectors like textiles, gems, and jewellery are particularly vulnerable, risking thousands of jobs.
  • This situation forces India into a complex foreign policy dilemma, balancing its critical relationships with Russia and the United States.

India’s strategic pivot towards discounted Russian crude following the Ukraine conflict yielded substantial economic benefits, estimated at over $17 billion in savings since early 2022. However, this advantage is now confronted by a significant economic counter-measure: new U.S. tariffs, up to 50%, on Indian imports. Analysts from the Global Trade Research Initiative (GTRI) project these tariffs could reduce Indian exports by more than 40%, translating to nearly $37 billion, within the current fiscal year. This economic hit is particularly acute for labour-intensive sectors such as textiles, gems, and jewellery, threatening thousands of jobs and posing a considerable political challenge for Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s administration.

Geopolitical Balancing Act

Beneath the surface of this economic calculus lies India’s intricate geopolitical balancing act. Despite global pressures, Russia remains an indispensable strategic partner for India, primarily due to its ongoing role as a critical supplier of defense equipment. According to Happymon Jacob, founder of Delhi’s Council for Strategic and Defence Research, Russia also provides geopolitical support in the continental sphere and political backing on sensitive matters, alongside opportunities for discounted oil, solidifying its value to New Delhi.

Simultaneously, the United States, under President Donald Trump, continues to be recognized as India’s most vital strategic ally. Washington views its relationship with New Delhi as paramount for countering China’s expanding influence in the Indo-Pacific region. This dual imperative forces India into a delicate geopolitical position, where choosing one partner definitively over the other is not currently a viable option, a sentiment echoed by strategic analysts.

The Path Forward

India’s dependency on Russian crude has grown significantly, now accounting for nearly 40% of its total oil imports, a sharp increase from negligible levels before the conflict. An abrupt cessation of these imports would not only represent a capitulation to external pressure but also present severe economic challenges. Major Indian refiners, including billionaire Mukesh Ambani’s Reliance Industries, which operates one of the world’s largest refining complexes, have been key beneficiaries and participants in these increased Russian oil purchases. In response to the escalating trade tensions, Indian government sources indicate a desire to mend ties with Washington, signaling openness to increase U.S. energy purchases while remaining hesitant to completely halt Russian oil. Diplomatic efforts are ongoing, with officials engaged in virtual dialogues covering trade, energy security, nuclear cooperation, and critical minerals exploration, highlighting the urgency of finding a pragmatic resolution to this complex geopolitical and economic dilemma.

Share